Current release: v1.9.0 Red/Blue split, checks and limits.
Previous release: v1.8.0 Recon threat intelligence, checks and limits.
Recon v0.2.0 source enhancement: commands, imports, compatibility and checks.
Recon P0 source addition: contract, checks and phase limits.
Security source enhancement: rename, checks and limitations.
Current patch: v1.1.1 changes and verification.
Prior nineteen-skill v1.1.0 checks and model trials: see v1.1.0 report. The reports below retain their original revision-specific outcomes.
Earlier seventeen-skill catalog: see the research addition and prior expansion report. The initial eleven-skill results below are historical.
Implementation and verification report
Date: 2026-11-07. Branch: codex/panda-suite. This is a local repository
implementation; no commit, push, package publication, or upstream modification
was performed.
Delivered
- Nine original skills plus the two unchanged upstream skills: eleven total.
- Portable root plugin manifest, Claude compatibility manifest, and local marketplace metadata for both hosts. No Codex fallback was needed.
- Thirty preserved upstream files with revision/file hashes and attribution.
- Skill-local routing, handoff, specification, and manual references.
- Structural validator, safe standalone copy utility, pinned missing-file restoration, evaluation preparation, and optional native Codex discovery check.
- English/Thai guides, architecture/research/integration/contract documentation, thirteen scenarios, real fixture workspaces, retained results, and an actual browser capture/manual.
Verified boundaries
| Check | Actual result |
|---|---|
Standard skill-creator quick validator |
All eleven skill folders passed |
| Suite structural validation | Eleven skills, YAML, references, manifests, scenario coverage passed |
| Tooling mutation tests | 23 tests passed, including review-derived link and late-collision regressions |
| Upstream integrity | All thirty mapped files match pinned SHA-256 values |
| Missing-file restore | Actual fetch of both pinned commits restored all thirty files into an otherwise empty temporary checkout; hashes passed |
| Claude Code 2.1.251 | Plugin and marketplace manifests validate; local component inventory lists eleven skills, zero agents/hooks/MCP servers |
| Codex 0.159.2 | Real plugin/read lists eleven skills from the portable package; skills/list discovers all eleven copied into a temporary repository |
| Browser-enabled manual variation | Actual local draft-save interaction and screenshot; success path only |
| Original behavioral exercise | 34 actual answers/logs, plus an independent audit; includes semantic failures and shared-context limitations |
| Fresh focused route | H loads only task, Lead, and function source; no extra workflow |
| Revised execution regression | Five supplied tests, extra boundary checks, and usage example passed; independently rerun supplied tests passed |
| Fresh plan follow-up | Proposed signature/error contract is consistent; existing two tests pass and source/tests remain unchanged |
| Clean package copy | Structural validation, vendor hashes, and all 23 tooling tests pass without Git history or bundled environment; tests use declared development dependencies |
Re-run commands are in README and evaluation guide. Detailed task outcomes, including new regression runs, are in the results.
The CLI component inventory estimated about 776 always-on tokens for all skill descriptions during the initial discovery run. This is a host estimate, not measured task consumption or a savings claim. The preserved upstream Buddhist Method description is substantially longer than Suite-authored descriptions.
Review corrections and limits
Independent implementation review reproduced unsupported reference-style links,
false rejection of titled links, and a late installation collision that could
misreport success. Regression tests now cover these paths. Suite also enforces its
canonical ./skills/ host path to catch configuration drift; Claude's extra skills
paths add to its default scan, so a different valid extra path does not itself
prove missing runtime discovery.
The original execution artifacts passed four supplied tests but violated a Unicode separator rule. They remain recorded as partial, and the fixture now includes that regression. The planning artifacts also had a missing-argument/error-contract inconsistency. Execute and Plan now explicitly check acceptance coverage and signature/error consistency. The original batched evaluations do not establish minimal isolated loading, repeatability, or improvement over baseline.
Persistent installation, interactive plugin model invocation, other hosts/OSes, production workflows, and statistically controlled performance comparisons were not tested. Native discovery and instruction-loaded task runs are separate evidence. Panda Debugger's pinned revision has no LICENSE file; public redistribution terms remain unresolved. Neither that omission nor any unrun check is presented as solved.
v1.3.0 — Panda Learn
See the release verification record for 21-skill packaging, host discovery, fixtures and documentation checks. The actual comparison retains ten native task trials: four selected pairs pass and two initial routing trials remain setup-confounded. The sampled baseline already succeeded; no improvement or learner-outcome advantage is established. Six further behavioral cases remain Not Run. Historical Refactor evaluation limits remain unchanged.
v1.4.0 — Panda Craft
See the release verification record for 22-skill packaging, host discovery, fixture, relative-path and documentation checks. The actual Craft trial passes in both direct-specialist and candidate arms, with no demonstrated incremental benefit. Seven additional behavioral cases and real external UI composition remain Not Run. The path normalization note records the presentation-only edits to historical evidence; results and authorization remain unchanged. No upstream license status or prior evaluation limitation is resolved by this release.
v1.5.0 — Panda Git
See Git contract and evaluation, actual trial comparison and release verification. Structural validity, host discovery and observed task behavior are separate. The initial classification failure is preserved; baseline success means these small trials do not establish incremental benefit.